When it comes to building a closet full of reliable basics, one question always pops up: Should I save my money or splurge on something higher quality?

The answer can vary from piece to piece. For example, items like basic white tanks tend to wear out quickly, so I usually lean toward saving. But for pieces I know I’ll wear often, I consider the “cost per wear” before deciding. Here, I’m comparing two popular crewnecks to help you figure out which option—save or splurge fits your lifestyle!

<h3>1. Save: Gildan Crewneck</h3>

A Gildan crewneck is the perfect choice if you’re looking for a budget-friendly basic that still gets the job done. It’s comfortable, easy to style, and comes in plenty of colors, making it great for everyday wear or layering. This option is ideal if you want something simple, don’t mind replacing it eventually, or enjoy switching up your outfits without overspending. It’s a practical, no-fuss pick for anyone who loves versatility on a budget.

<h3>2. Splurge: Melville Crewneck</h3>

If you prefer a crewneck with a more elevated fit and feel, the Melville version may be worth the splurge. It typically offers softer fabric, a more flattering silhouette, and a quality that holds up better over time. This is a great option if you love wearing crewnecks regularly and want one that looks good, feels great, and lasts through frequent washes and wear. Investing a little more upfront can make a difference if this becomes one of your go-to wardrobe staples.

Choosing to save or splurge isn’t about one option being “better”—it’s about finding what works for you. Both crewnecks have their strengths, and each can fit different needs. Whether you pick the simple and affordable Gildan or the higher-quality Melville, the best choice is the one that makes you feel comfortable, confident, and happy with your wardrobe.